Overview
Primary failure of tooth eruption (PFE) is a rare developmental disorder characterized by the incomplete eruption of teeth, predominantly affecting primary molars but more commonly observed in permanent dentition, particularly posterior teeth like the first molars. This condition disrupts the delicate balance between pro-eruptive and anti-resistance axes, which are crucial for normal tooth eruption. The pro-eruptive axis involves bone deposition and root growth, while the anti-resistance axis facilitates bone resorption to clear the path for tooth emergence. PFE is often associated with genetic mutations, most notably in the PTH1R gene, which plays a pivotal role in the parathyroid hormone-related peptide (PTHrP) signaling pathway essential for tooth eruption. Understanding the genetic underpinnings of PFE is crucial for accurate diagnosis and tailored management strategies.
Pathophysiology
PFE arises from disruptions in the intricate mechanisms governing tooth eruption, primarily involving the interplay between the pro-eruptive and anti-resistance axes. The pro-eruptive axis drives tooth eruption through processes such as bone deposition and root elongation, whereas the anti-resistance axis manages bone resorption to facilitate the tooth's path through the alveolar bone. Key to this process is the PTHrP-PTH1R signaling pathway, where mutations in the PTH1R gene can severely impair tooth eruption [PMID:29544499]. Novel genetic studies have identified various PTH1R variants, including exonic and intronic mutations, which can lead to proteolytic degradation, truncation, or single amino acid exchanges that disrupt receptor function [PMID:27898723]. These genetic alterations impair calcium homeostasis and bone formation, critical for tooth eruption, leading to conditions such as tooth impaction and encapsulation by a bony crypt [PMID:29544499].
Beyond PTH1R, other genes like KMT2C have been implicated in PFE, suggesting a broader genetic spectrum underlying the condition [PMID:31712638]. Mutations in KMT2C, involved in epigenetic regulation, have been identified in families with multiple affected individuals, indicating that disruptions in dental follicle cell differentiation and bone remodeling processes, mediated by genes such as AMELX, AMBN, Periostin, and RUNX2, may also contribute to PFE [PMID:19419450]. These findings underscore the complexity of genetic factors influencing tooth eruption and highlight the importance of comprehensive genetic screening in diagnosing PFE.
Epidemiology
PFE is a relatively rare condition with a reported prevalence of approximately 0.06% in the general population [PMID:41026269]. The condition predominantly affects permanent teeth, with a ratio of about 3:1 compared to primary teeth, particularly impacting posterior teeth such as the first molars [PMID:41026269]. Eruption failure specifically for primary and permanent molars ranges from 0.02% to 1.7%, indicating a significant variability in incidence [PMID:41026269]. The autosomal dominant inheritance pattern is a notable feature, with familial history playing a crucial role in identifying cases [PMID:39327493]. Studies have documented multigenerational transmission of PFE within families, emphasizing the genetic basis and incomplete penetrance observed in some cases [PMID:31730001]. For instance, a four-generation family with multiple affected members across two generations highlights the hereditary nature of the condition [PMID:31712638]. Understanding these epidemiological patterns aids in early recognition and genetic counseling for affected families.
Clinical Presentation
PFE manifests primarily through incomplete tooth eruption, typically affecting permanent teeth more frequently than primary teeth, with a notable predilection for posterior teeth such as the first molars [PMID:41026269]. Affected teeth often fail to erupt fully, sometimes partially emerging before ceasing progress, leading to submersion below the gingival margin [PMID:34897565]. This results in characteristic clinical features including an open bite, particularly in the posterior region, and can involve unilateral or bilateral involvement [PMID:29544499]. Radiographic imaging typically reveals no physical obstruction but shows reduced vertical height of the alveolar bone around the affected tooth compared to adjacent teeth [PMID:41026269]. Patients may present with infraoccluded teeth, where the crowns remain below the occlusal plane, often accompanied by growth deficiency of the alveolar process [PMID:27898723]. These clinical manifestations are consistent with the underlying genetic disruptions affecting bone formation and tooth eruption pathways.
In some cases, PFE can be subtle, with initial symptoms limited to primary teeth before manifesting more prominently in permanent dentition [PMID:30904994]. Additionally, while PFE primarily impacts dental development, some studies have noted associations with systemic symptoms during primary tooth eruption, such as increased drooling and diarrhea, though these are relatively uncommon outside the eruption period [PMID:14528780]. These varied presentations underscore the importance of thorough clinical evaluation and genetic analysis for accurate diagnosis.
Diagnosis
Diagnosing PFE involves a comprehensive approach combining detailed patient history, clinical examination, and advanced genetic testing. Radiographic imaging is fundamental, typically revealing teeth that are non-ankylosed but fail to erupt fully, with characteristic lower alveolar bone height around the affected tooth [PMID:41026269]. Genetic analysis, particularly sequencing of the PTH1R gene, has become a cornerstone in confirming PFE. Studies have identified multiple PTH1R variants, including exonic and intronic mutations, haploinsufficiency, and novel nonsense variants, which can confirm the diagnosis [PMID:39327493, PMID:31730001]. Genetic counseling is essential, especially given that unaffected parents can be carriers of non-penetrant mutations, complicating clinical assessment [PMID:31730001].
Differentiating PFE from other eruption disorders such as mesiodens-related malocclusion (MFE) and ankylosis is critical. Type II PFE, characterized by differential eruption patterns, can mimic ankylosis, necessitating careful radiographic and clinical differentiation [PMID:34897565]. Additionally, ruling out systemic or syndromic disorders like regional cleidocranial dysplasia, odontodysplasia, osteopetrosis, and GAPO syndrome is important [PMID:29544499]. Genetic testing for PTH1R mutations, along with consideration of other candidate genes like AMELX, AMBN, Periostin, and RUNX2, enhances diagnostic accuracy, particularly in familial cases [PMID:19419450]. Early identification through genetic screening can prevent the initiation of ineffective orthodontic treatments and guide appropriate management strategies.
Differential Diagnosis
Differentiating PFE from other dental conditions is crucial for accurate management. Ankylosis, characterized by fusion of the tooth to the alveolar bone, can present similarly but typically involves physical obstruction visible on radiographs, unlike PFE where no such obstruction is found [PMID:34897565]. Type II PFE, with its unique eruption patterns, can further complicate diagnosis by mimicking ankylosis, particularly in cases involving the first and second molars [PMID:34897565]. Systemic or syndromic disorders such as regional cleidocranial dysplasia, odontodysplasia, Albers-Schönberg osteopetrosis, and GAPO syndrome must also be considered, as they can present with similar dental manifestations but have distinct systemic features [PMID:29544499]. Age is another critical factor; younger patients may exhibit overlapping symptoms, making differentiation challenging [PMID:23784709]. Genetic analysis, particularly focusing on PTH1R mutations, is pivotal in distinguishing PFE from mechanical causes, ensuring that appropriate diagnostic pathways are followed.
Management
The management of PFE is challenging due to the genetic basis of the condition, often rendering conventional orthodontic interventions ineffective. Orthodontic traction frequently fails to achieve tooth eruption and can lead to complications such as root cementum formation and potential ankylosis or intrusion of adjacent teeth [PMID:41026269]. Given these limitations, genetic characterization of PTH1R variants is crucial for tailoring therapeutic approaches. Identification of specific mutations can guide clinicians in avoiding ineffective treatments and focusing on multidisciplinary strategies post-growth completion [PMID:31730001].
Multidisciplinary management typically involves collaboration between orthodontists, oral surgeons, and geneticists. Post-growth, interventions may include surgical exposure of impacted teeth, guided eruption techniques, or orthodontic appliances designed to minimize complications [PMID:30904994]. However, complete resolution of issues like posterior open bite may not always be achievable, necessitating a focus on functional and aesthetic outcomes rather than absolute correction [PMID:30904994]. Long-term follow-up is essential to monitor dental development and manage potential complications, such as persistent eruption issues and skeletal abnormalities, which can arise due to the underlying genetic predispositions [PMID:27898723]. Understanding the specific genetic mutations involved helps in predicting outcomes and tailoring follow-up care to address individual patient needs effectively.
Prognosis & Follow-up
The prognosis for patients with PFE is influenced significantly by early diagnosis and genetic understanding. Early identification allows clinicians to avoid ineffective treatments like continuous archwire application, which can exacerbate issues such as ankylosis or tooth intrusion [PMID:34897565]. Genetic counseling is vital, particularly in assessing unaffected carrier parents to understand hereditary risks and guide long-term follow-up for affected individuals [PMID:31730001]. Regular monitoring post-diagnosis is crucial to track dental development and manage complications, ensuring that any emerging issues are addressed promptly. For instance, persistent eruption problems and skeletal abnormalities can be better managed with a proactive approach informed by genetic insights [PMID:27898723]. Long-term follow-up should consider both dental and skeletal outcomes, with multidisciplinary care facilitating comprehensive management strategies tailored to individual genetic profiles.
Special Populations
PFE exhibits a notable hereditary component, making genetic counseling particularly important for families with multiple affected members. The condition often follows an autosomal dominant pattern, with incomplete penetrance observed, indicating that unaffected parents can be carriers of non-penetrant mutations [PMID:31730001]. This genetic predisposition suggests that certain ethnic or familial groups might have a higher prevalence of specific PTH1R variants, underscoring the need for ethnicity-specific genetic screening protocols [PMID:21404329]. For example, studies focusing on Japanese families have highlighted the prevalence of particular PTH1R mutations, emphasizing the importance of tailored genetic screening approaches in diverse populations [PMID:21404329]. Understanding these genetic underpinnings is crucial for early diagnosis and appropriate management in familial contexts, ensuring that affected individuals receive timely and targeted care.
Key Recommendations
References
1 Hu X, Guo A, Xie Y, Mo S. Mechanisms of primary failure of eruption: a new model of multidimensional framework. Progress in orthodontics 2025. link 2 Modafferi C, Tabolacci E, Lo Vecchio F, Cassano I, Bertozzi R, Fargnoli A et al.. New Insight into the genotype-phenotype correlation of PTH1R variants and primary failure of tooth eruption on an Italian Cohort. European journal of human genetics : EJHG 2024. link 3 Grippaudo C, D'Apolito I, Cafiero C, Re A, Chiurazzi P, Frazier-Bowers SA. Validating clinical characteristic of primary failure of eruption (PFE) associated with PTH1R variants. Progress in orthodontics 2021. link 4 Grippaudo C, Cafiero C, D'Apolito I, Re A, Genuardi M, Chiurazzi P et al.. A novel nonsense PTH1R variant shows incomplete penetrance of primary failure of eruption: a case report. BMC oral health 2019. link 5 Assiry AA, Albalawi AM, Zafar MS, Khan SD, Ullah A, Almatrafi A et al.. KMT2C, a histone methyltransferase, is mutated in a family segregating non-syndromic primary failure of tooth eruption. Scientific reports 2019. link 6 Hanisch M, Hanisch L, Kleinheinz J, Jung S. Primary failure of eruption (PFE): a systematic review. Head & face medicine 2018. link 7 Grippaudo C, Cafiero C, D'Apolito I, Ricci B, Frazier-Bowers SA. Primary failure of eruption: Clinical and genetic findings in the mixed dentition. The Angle orthodontist 2018. link 8 Subramanian H, Döring F, Kollert S, Rukoyatkina N, Sturm J, Gambaryan S et al.. PTH1R Mutants Found in Patients with Primary Failure of Tooth Eruption Disrupt G-Protein Signaling. PloS one 2016. link 9 Frazier-Bowers SA, Simmons D, Koehler K, Zhou J. Genetic analysis of familial non-syndromic primary failure of eruption. Orthodontics & craniofacial research 2009. link 10 Li XX, Wang MT, Wu ZF, Sun Q, Ono N, Nagata M et al.. Etiological Mechanisms and Genetic/Biological Modulation Related to PTH1R in Primary Failure of Tooth Eruption. Calcified tissue international 2024. link 11 Aziz S, Hermann NV, Dunø M, Risom L, Daugaard-Jensen J, Kreiborg S. Primary failure of eruption of teeth in two siblings with a novel mutation in the PTH1R gene. European archives of paediatric dentistry : official journal of the European Academy of Paediatric Dentistry 2019. link 12 Hendricks HM, Bencharit S, Seaman W, Frazier-Bowers SA. In silico and functional evaluation of PTH1R mutations found in patients with primary failure of eruption (PFE). Orthodontics & craniofacial research 2017. link 13 Anthonappa RP, King NM. Primary failure of eruption or severe infra-occlusion: a misdiagnosis?. European archives of paediatric dentistry : official journal of the European Academy of Paediatric Dentistry 2013. link 14 Yamaguchi T, Hosomichi K, Narita A, Shirota T, Tomoyasu Y, Maki K et al.. Exome resequencing combined with linkage analysis identifies novel PTH1R variants in primary failure of tooth eruption in Japanese. Journal of bone and mineral research : the official journal of the American Society for Bone and Mineral Research 2011. link 15 Frazier-Bowers SA, Simmons D, Wright JT, Proffit WR, Ackerman JL. Primary failure of eruption and PTH1R: the importance of a genetic diagnosis for orthodontic treatment planning. American journal of orthodontics and dentofacial orthopedics : official publication of the American Association of Orthodontists, its constituent societies, and the American Board of Orthodontics 2010. link 16 Peretz B, Ram D, Hermida L, Otero MM. Systemic manifestations during eruption of primary teeth in infants. Journal of dentistry for children (Chicago, Ill.) 2003. link 17 Pytlik W. Primary failure of eruption: a case report. International dental journal 1991. link